Heavenly Pizza Button: Order OnlineHeavenly Pizza Button: Call Now
For DELIVERY or CARRYOUT from our Tiffin Store: 419.448.1427

Our Menu

The prices and items listed on our website and menu are not guaranteed and are subject to change without notice.

Want to see it in print?

Click the image on the right to download and print a PDF of our menu!
Heavenly Pizza Menu - Thumbnail
Menu Selections

Pizza

10"
14"
16" or
Jr. Jumbo
Jumbo
Item/Size
12"
1 Item
Cheese
Premium Toppings: Extra Cheese, Chicken, or Bacon
Per Extra Item
4 Item
3 Item
2 Item
$10.95
$2.50
$1.10
$15.35
$14.25
$13.15
$12.05
$7.95
$2.00
$0.95
$11.75
$10.80
$9.85
$8.90
$35.95
$32.95
$29.95
$26.95
$15.25
$3.50
$1.75
$21.95
$20.20
$18.45
$16.70
$12.95
$3.00
$1.50
$17.95
$16.45
$14.95
$13.45
$24.95
$6.00
$3.00

NEW! Crust options for 10" pizzas:

Artisan Vegan +$4.00 (Gluten-free dough is made in a non-gluten-free environment; cross-contact may occur.)
‍
Cauliflower +$4.00

Thick or Thin CRUST? Extra sauce?

Thin or thick crust and extra sauce for any pizza available upon request at no additional cost.

Toppings:

Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Ham, Sausage, Italian Sausage, Green Peppers, Onions, Green Olives, Black Olives, Mild Pepper Rings, Tomatoes, Jalapeno Peppers, Pineapple

Additional Premium Toppings:

Available at additional Cost: Eggs, Steak, Meatballs
Pizza Picture

Specialty Pizza

10"
12"
14"
16" or
Jr. Jumbo
Jumbo
Item/Size
$17.95
$17.95
$17.95
$17.95
$17.95
$17.95
$17.95
$15.35
$11.75
$11.75
$11.75
$11.75
$11.75
$11.75
$11.75
$11.75
$11.75
$35.95
$35.95
$35.95
$35.95
$35.95
$35.95
$35.95
$21.95
$21.95
$21.95
$21.95
$21.95
$21.95
$21.95
$15.35
$15.35
$15.35
$15.35
$15.35
$15.35
$15.35
$15.35
$17.95
$17.95
$19.95
$21.95
$35.95
$35.95
Philly Steak
A deluxe combination of steak, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, mayonnaise and cheese
$11.75
$15.35
$17.95
$21.95
$35.95
$11.75
$15.35
$17.95
$21.95
$35.95
$11.75
$15.35
$17.95
$21.95
$35.95

NEW! Crust options for 10" pizzas:

Gluten-Free +$4.00 (Gluten-free dough is made in a non-gluten-free environment; cross-contact may occur.)
Cauliflower +$4.00

Thick or Thin CRUST? Extra sauce?

Thin or thick crust and extra sauce for any pizza available upon request at no additional cost.

Toppings:

Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Ham, Sausage, Italian Sausage, Green Peppers, Onions, Green Olives, Black Olives, Mild Pepper Rings, Tomatoes, Jalapeno Peppers, Pineapple

Premium Toppings:

Available at additional Cost: Bacon, Extra Cheese, Chicken, Eggs, Steak, Meatballs
Sub Sandwich Picture

Subs & Foldovers

What’s a Foldover?

A Foldover has Sub ingredients inside pizza dough, then (wait for it...) it’s folded over!
Half Sub
(8")
Whole Sub
(12")
Small (12")
Foldover
Large (16")
Foldover
Item/Size
$11.95
$11.95
$11.95
$11.95
$11.95
$11.95
$8.95
$7.95
$7.95
$7.95
$7.95
$7.95
$7.95
$15.95
$15.95
$15.95
$15.95
$15.95
$15.95
$8.95
$8.95
$8.95
$8.95
$8.95
Specialty Sub Sandwich Picture

Specialty Subs & Foldovers

What’s a Foldover?

A Foldover has Sub ingredients inside pizza dough, then (wait for it...) it’s folded over!
Half Sub
(8")
Whole Sub
(12")
Small (12")
Foldover
Large (16")
Foldover
Item/Size
$12.95
$12.95
$12.95
$12.95
$12.95
$12.95
$9.95
$8.95
$8.95
$8.95
$8.95
$8.95
$8.95
$8.95
$16.95
$16.95
$16.95
$16.95
$16.95
$16.95
$9.95
$9.95
$9.95
$9.95
$9.95
$9.95
$12.95
$16.95
BLT
Bacon, Lettuce, Cheese, Tomato, and Mayo
$8.95
$9.95
$12.95
$16.95
$8.95
$9.95
$12.95
$16.95
Meatball
Meatballs, Cheese, Sauce
Chef Salad Picture

Salads

Small
Large
Family
Item/Size
$28.95
$28.95
$27.95
$28.95
$9.95
$8.45
$8.45
$7.45
$8.45
$9.95
$9.95
$8.95
Antipasto Salad
A generous portion of Lettuce, Tomato, Pepperoni, Mild Pepper Rings, Onions, Ham, and Cheese
Chef Salad
A large serving of Lettuce, Tomato, Ham, Onion, Cheese, and Egg
Chicken Caesar Salad
Lettuce, Cheese, and Chicken
Toss Salad
Lettuce, Tomato, Onions, and Cheese

Salad Dressings

French, Fat Free French, Lite Italian, Ranch, Lite Ranch, Caesar, Thousand Island, Honey Mustard, Blue Cheese, and Heavenly Pizza Homemade Dressing. (Ask about our House Dressing to go!)

Pasta

Single Serving
Family Size
Item
$28.95
$8.95
$10.45
$9.95
$27.95
$29.95
Cheese Lasagna
Meat Lasagna
Deluxe Lasagna

Beverages

12 oz. Can
20 oz. Bottle
Item/Size
2 Liter Bottle
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Dr. Pepper, Mt. Dew, Starry, Mug Root Beer
$1.25
$2.50
$3.75
Diet Dr. Pepper
-
$2.50
-
Cherry Pepsi
-
$2.50
$3.75
Desert Pizza Picture

Appetizers, Desserts, & Extras

Small
Item/Size
Large
Family Size
$7.95
‍Order of 12
$11.95
‍Order of 24
$7.95
‍Order of 12
$7.95
‍Order of 6
$7.95
‍Order of 12
Breadstix
+ $4.00 for Gluten-free Artisan or Cauliflower. Small size only.
Cheese Breadstix
+ $4.00 for Gluten-free Artisan or Cauliflower. Small size only.
Pepperoni Roll
Limited Availability
Pizza by the Slice
Each
Add House Dressing
Add house dressing to any sub or foldover
Extra Sauce
Cup
Garlic Bread
Parmesan Stix
+ $4.00 for Gluten-free Artisan or Cauliflower. Small size only.
-
Cookies
Garlic Butter
Each
$10.95
Order of 10
$0.50 each
$0.95 each
$3.50
$0.50
$2.00
$0.75
$10.95
Order of 10
Pizza Cookie
$6.95
Pizza Brownie
$1.75 each
Brownies
$6.95
Cinnamon Stix
+ $4.00 for Gluten-free Artisan or Cauliflower. Small size only.
$7.95
Order of 6
-
$21.95
‍Order of 48
$11.95
‍Order of 24
$11.95
Order of 24
–
$21.95
‍Order of 48
$21.95
‍Order of 48
$21.95
Order of 48
$11.95
‍Order of 24
$28.95
Order of 30
$28.95
Order of 30
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–

Heavenly Pizza | Tiffin

Heavenly Pizza Tiffin Hours  | Monday thru Saturday 11 AM - 9 PM. Closed Sunday.
Call us to arrange special delivery times and additional availability.

A 3% convenience fee is added to all purchases made with debit or credit cards.

Heavenly Pizza Tiffin Delivery Area | Touch-free delivery available to Tiffin, Bascom, Bettsville, Bloomville, Fort Seneca, McCutchensville, Melmore, New Riegel, Old Fort, Republic, Clinton Lake, Leafy Oaks, and Walnut Grove. A nominal delivery charge applies. Tips for drivers are appreciated!

Heavenly Pizza Phone Number

2 Main St. Tiffin, OH 44883 | © 2024 Heavenly Pizza Tiffin. All Rights Reserved.
‍

Web design by Thinking Small, LLC